
| Brought to you by: |
 |
'07 | #40 General McQuarrie
- Empire Strikes Back (Reviewed 12-06-2007)
Includes:
Removable Helmet
Blaster Pistol
Commemorative Coin
Click thumbnail for large image Spice:
It's hard to say whether or
not Ralph McQuarrie would care less if he ever became an action figure. I'd
highly doubt that was a high priority when he generated the concept art for the
original trilogy. In light of this speculation, you can say it was a class act
on the part of Hasbro to not only honor McQuarrie with the signature series
in the thirtieth anniversary collection, but to make his likeness in an action
figure was nothing short of admirable. However I'd have to wonder why he
wouldn't be in the Expanded Universe category vs. the Empire Strikes back, but
this isn't the biggest let down of the fortieth figure. |
Click thumbnail for large image It's
too bad they didn't put a little more thought into generating the action figure
for one of the greatest icons in Star Wars. The path to hell is once again paved
with good intention as multi-million dollar save-a-buck Hasbro craps the bed in
one of their greatest cheapskate moves of all time. Instead of the creation of an
all-new sculpt they simply added a head to the body of Major Bren Derlin. What
makes it flat out horrible is the way the head fits on the body. Or what I'd say
the lack thereof. The bad combination of Ralph's ducktail and the high collar on
the jacket, the head simply pops off without hardly any movement. |
Click thumbnail for large image This
creates further problems when you attempt to put the head gear on as well. I'm
sorry but the head falling off endlessly and needlessly brings us back to the
question of how does something like this get past quality control if they have
such a thing? No ankle or knee movement leaves even more to be desired. In fact
the only articulation it really has in the rolling elbows, which I loathe. The
arms and legs move and with a head that constantly falls off, you'd be better
off using a vintage mold from Kenner if you have to be so cheap. |
FINAL
THOUGHTS:
 |
Spice -
It's just not good enough to put a name to a face for nothing more
than to save a dollar. If you are going to distribute this to the
number one fan base in the world, put quality and originality into the
man you are striving so hard to honor and pay tribute to. Isn't that
what made Star Wars so special? Do
everything you can do be the best, and a half-cocked effort just
doesn't cut it for a man who meant as much to the Saga as Ralph
McQuarrie does. Great idea, awful execution and follow through. |
| Grades |
-
|
| Visual Impact |
7.0
|
| Detail &
Paint |
6.9
|
| Accessories / Weapons |
6.8
|
| Articulation / Function |
4.1
|
| Overall |
3.8
|
| +
|
Great way
to honor an all time legend. |
| - |
The biggest problem is the jaw
line. |
| +
|
Hasbro could use this with #18 to fire everyone in quality control. |
| - |
Great way to drop the ball by
being cheap. |
(Figure '07 | #040, Asst. No.
87500, Item No. 87393, Backing Card P/N
6606728400, Window Insert P/N
660673700
What's your opinion? Post your
feedback here in the
Forums.